QUICK TAKE | Can Restaurants Still Force You to Pay a Service Charge? Seven Things to Know

Last Updated:
The Delhi High Court clarified on November 19 that restaurant associations have received no interim protection against the ban on compulsory service charges. Their appeals will be heard, while the earlier ruling continues to apply
The Delhi High Court clarified on November 19 that restaurant associations have received no interim protection against the ban on compulsory service charges.
The Delhi High Court clarified on November 19 that restaurant associations have received no interim protection against the ban on compulsory service charges. Credits: ANI

1. What has the Delhi High Court clarified?

Restaurants cannot cite the pending appeals as permission to impose mandatory service charges. The court admitted the restaurant associations’ appeals but said it had granted no interim relief against the March 28, 2025 judgment upholding the consumer protection guidelines.

2. Can a restaurant automatically add the charge?

The CCPA’s July 2022 guidelines prohibit adding service charges automatically or by default. Customers must be told that payment is voluntary and left to their discretion. Restaurants also cannot collect a compulsory service charge under another name.

Sign up for Open Magazine's ad-free experience
Enjoy uninterrupted access to premium content and insights.

3. What if the menu mentions a 10% service charge?

Printing it on the menu does not make it compulsory. The single judge rejected the argument that entering a restaurant and ordering after seeing the charge amounted to an agreement to pay it. Customers retain the choice over a voluntary contribution.

4. Is service charge a government tax?

A service charge is collected by the establishment. Applicable taxes are separate. The guidelines say menu prices already cover the food and the service involved in providing it, while restaurants remain free to set those prices.

open magazine cover
Open Magazine Latest Edition is Out Now!

The Wealth Issue 2026

06 Nov 2026 - Vol 05 | Issue 45

Portraits of Dreamers and Doers under 35

Read Now The Wealth Issue 2026

5. Can a restaurant refuse service if you decline?

The guidelines prohibit making payment of a service charge a condition for entry or service. Diners can ask for it to be removed from the bill and still choose to leave a tip after assessing their experience.

6. Why are restaurant associations challenging the ruling?

NRAI and FHRAI argue that service charges are an established industry practice used to distribute money among employees, including kitchen staff who rarely receive tips directly. They contend that advance disclosure should permit collection. The appeals remain to be decided.

7. Where can diners complain?

First ask the restaurant to remove the compulsory charge and retain the bill. The CCPA guidelines provide for complaints to the National Consumer Helpline on 1915 or through its app. Consumers can also approach the appropriate consumer commission for redress.