EXPLAINED | Why Are COP31 Climate Talks on the Brink of Collapse?

Last Updated:
In Antalya, negotiators have put a figure on how much warming to expect and how much carbon they hope to capture. The number they dropped was the $120 billion that developing countries wanted to help them live with the consequences
Netherlands' Minister for Climate and Green Growth Stientje van Veldhoven addresses the media during the UN Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Antalya
Netherlands' Minister for Climate and Green Growth Stientje van Veldhoven addresses the media during the UN Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Antalya Credits: Getty

Tripling a sum of money ought to be straightforward. The difficulty at the UN climate summit in Antalya is that governments have yet to agree which number to multiply by three. On Monday, November 16, the presidency offered them an answer. Paragraph 73 of its first draft put the proposed target for adaptation finance at a minimum of $120 billion. It also asked developed countries to explain how they would get there.

Sign up for Open Magazine's ad-free experience
Enjoy uninterrupted access to premium content and insights.

By two o’clock on Sunday morning, the $120 billion target had gone. In its place was a proposal for a technical report. Governments would consider their options for a starting figure in November 2027. Elsewhere in those same ten pages, the authors had managed to be quite precise about money. Paragraph 19 put developing countries’ adaptation needs at $305 billion a year. The difficulty in Antalya was agreeing how much help those countries could count on.

open magazine cover
Open Magazine Latest Edition is Out Now!

The Wealth Issue 2026

06 Nov 2026 - Vol 05 | Issue 45

Portraits of Dreamers and Doers under 35

Read Now The Wealth Issue 2026

The talks in Turkey were already into their second day of overtime. Murat Kurum, the Turkish environment minister presiding over COP31, believed he had a text governments could accept. Negotiators had about three hours to raise objections or suggest changes before the planned plenary, the Associated Press reported. European and Pacific delegations had been pressing to restore an explicit commitment to move away from fossil fuels. African negotiators wanted a figure they could take home. The presidency needed both groups, and the countries resisting their demands, to let the same document through.

Ghana’s environment minister, Zanetor Agyeman-Rawlings, who chairs the African Group of negotiators, had already explained the mood on her side of the table. “We did not come here to beg,” she said, according to the BBC. Her objection went to the purpose of the money. Governments whose people had contributed relatively little to the warming were having to find room in their budgets for its consequences. They had come to Antalya to settle how much of that bill wealthy countries would share.

What happened to the $120 billion?

The trouble began with a promise made a year earlier in Belém, Brazil. Governments called for efforts to at least triple adaptation finance by 2035. That gave them a multiplier and a deadline. They left the baseline open. An accountant trying to measure progress would still need to know the starting year, which financial flows to include and what those flows amounted to. Pick a different starting figure and governments can claim success having delivered substantially different sums.

The $120 billion in Monday’s draft would have supplied a floor. It would also have given governments, journalists and the people paying taxes in donor countries a reasonably simple test in 2035. Monday’s text went one step further by asking developed countries for a route to the target. That would have made it possible to judge progress along the way. A target that requires ten years of steadily rising contributions is a different budget proposition from one governments hope to meet with a late surge.

Governments whose people had contributed relatively little to the warming were having to find room in their budgets for its consequences. They had come to Antalya to settle how much of that bill wealthy countries would share
Governments whose people had contributed relatively little to the warming were having to find room in their budgets for its consequences. They had come to Antalya to settle how much of that bill wealthy countries would share Credits: Getty

Sunday’s version gives the work a different timetable. Paragraph 51 would send options for a baseline to next year’s meeting. Paragraph 52 would put the path to tripling finance up for discussion. An Antalya–Addis Ababa road map would examine sources and access. Any of that work could make it easier for a government to obtain funding. For a treasury preparing its next budget, however, each step leaves the eventual amount open. The $120 billion that disappeared was a proposal. No recipient had been allocated a share of it.

A nearby paragraph illustrates how precisely governments can write when they have settled the arithmetic. In paragraph 54, the same Sunday draft discusses money flowing through a narrower group of institutions, including the Adaptation Fund and the Least Developed Countries Fund. Here it identifies the starting year, 2022, and the deadline for tripling annual outflows, 2030. A reader can go back to the accounts and work out what success would look like. For the wider 2035 promise, doing that calculation still requires another round of diplomacy.

What the money buys in Tuvalu

On Fogafale, home to roughly half of Tuvalu’s population, adaptation has measurements residents can recognise. The second phase of a coastal protection project aims to protect 800 metres of vulnerable shoreline and create about eight hectares of raised land. Australia, New Zealand and the United States are funding the work, according to the UN Development Programme. The earlier phase received $36 million from the Green Climate Fund, with Tuvalu contributing $2.9 million in co-financing. On an island exposed to erosion and flooding, a financing agreement can alter how much usable ground people have beneath their feet.

Tuvalu also wanted the words “fossil fuels” restored to the Antalya agreement. Its climate minister, Maina Talia, put the case succinctly in remarks reported by the BBC: “We’re talking about the root cause of all of this.” Coastal protection and emissions cuts answer different questions for his country. The first buys some safety for people living on Fogafale now. The second helps determine the conditions those defences will face over their lifetime. Tuvalu has good reason to read both sections of the agreement.

The UN Environment Programme estimates that developing countries will need about $305 billion a year for adaptation by 2035. It measured international public adaptation finance flowing from developed to developing countries at $28.2 billion to $31.7 billion in 2024. The first number covers estimated needs. The second counts one source of funding in an earlier year. Even had the $120 billion target survived intact, it would have amounted to about two-fifths of estimated annual needs in 2035. That gives a sense of the scale of the request the African Group took into the room.

The two words Dubai could say

In 2023, at COP28 in Dubai, governments agreed to call for a transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. In Antalya, the argument was over whether they could say it again. The first draft had explicitly addressed fossil fuels. Thursday’s revision removed the language. By Saturday, the European Union and Saudi Arabia, on opposing sides of the dispute, had been brought together to seek a compromise. Panama and Pacific island countries were among those pressing to put the commitment back. A summit set up to discuss implementation was struggling to name the thing governments had agreed to implement.

Kurum and Australia’s Chris Bowen, who led the negotiations, found a way for both sides to recognise their position on the first page. Sunday’s opening sentence recalls the Dubai consensus “in its entirety”. The 2023 commitment is therefore within reach of anyone prepared to follow the reference. An energy minister reading the Antalya draft itself, however, can go from the first page to the tenth without encountering the words “fossil fuels”. For countries that had fought to get the phrase into a global agreement after nearly three decades of summits, the distinction was worth a confrontation.

There is substance to Bowen’s argument that governments should get on with building a cleaner energy system. The draft sets a global aim for electricity to supply 35 per cent of final energy consumption by 2035. It addresses grids, storage and efficiency, the practical investments needed to electrify more of the economy. But an electrification target leaves open how the electricity is generated. A government can support that target while retaining considerable freedom over the future of its coal and gas plants.

That freedom helps explain the fight over carbon capture. The Sunday text envisages deploying carbon capture, utilisation and storage at a scale of one billion tonnes globally by 2035. It describes this as a collective aspiration and singles out industries where emissions are particularly difficult to cut. France’s ecological transition minister, Monique Barbut, had warned that promoting the technology could give producers cover to keep burning fossil fuels. AFP reported that the push for carbon capture survived the overnight negotiations. The date and scale survived with it. A delegate looking for equivalent precision on adaptation finance had to turn back to Monday’s discarded text.

Why India reads the same draft differently

India came to Antalya asking for predictable finance and for governments to retain control over how they make the transition. Its official opening statement put adaptation and equity at the centre of the negotiations. In a ministerial intervention on November 16, India argued that developing countries needed finance, access to technology and the capacity to manage the consequences for workers and communities. Those positions make it possible for Delhi to welcome one part of the compromise and have serious grounds to question another.

Hindustan Times reported that dropping explicit fossil-fuel language from Thursday’s draft was consistent with India’s stated position. The same revision took out a financial target developing countries had sought. It would be a mistake to read India’s preference for deciding its own energy mix as indifference to the financing dispute. It would be equally misleading to give Delhi and Tuvalu a single position simply because both are developing countries. The two have overlapping claims on richer nations and different reasons for caring about the wording of an energy transition.

There is one forecast the presidency was prepared to put in writing. Paragraph 11 of Sunday’s draft says peak global warming is expected to exceed 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels in the next few years. The document retains the Paris temperature goal and calls for limiting how far warming goes beyond it and for how long. Reuters reported that adoption would mark the first such acknowledgement at a COP. For Tuvalu, either dimension of an overshoot matters. A future return to a lower temperature offers little comfort for losses the draft itself acknowledges could be irreversible.

By Sunday morning the presidency had counted 96 countries that had submitted national adaptation plans. Its draft urged them to put those plans into effect. Each government that does so will have to make choices as concrete as the one on Fogafale: which stretch of shore to protect, how high to build and how much its own treasury can contribute. In Antalya, negotiators could turn to paragraph 19 for the estimated scale of the need. For the starting figure against which they could measure the international response, paragraph 51 gave them a date. They could come back in November next year.