Sandpapergate Scandal: Eleven Men Played. Three Paid the Price. Can Cricket Australia Explain the Count?

Last Updated:
Eight years after Cape Town, Cameron Bancroft says he withheld the truth from investigators. Australia has every reason to question his word. The trouble for the gentleman’s game is deciding which version of his word to question
Eleven Australians played at Cape Town. A camera caught Bancroft cheating. Three men went home. Eight years later, the gentleman’s game owes us an answer: how did Cricket Australia establish that only three knew?
Eleven Australians played at Cape Town. A camera caught Bancroft cheating. Three men went home. Eight years later, the gentleman’s game owes us an answer: how did Cricket Australia establish that only three knew? Credits: Getty

Cameron Bancroft put the sandpaper down the front of his trousers. By then, it scarcely mattered where he put it. A television camera at Newlands had already done the first part of Cricket Australia’s investigation for it. The pictures identified the Australian fielder who had worked on the ball. Establishing who else knew what he was doing would require the cooperation of the men who had played that Test. Eight years later, Bancroft has explained precisely how much cooperation the investigators got from him.

Sign up for Open Magazine's ad-free experience
Enjoy uninterrupted access to premium content and insights.

“When I was questioned during Cricket Australia’s investigation, I did not give a complete and truthful account,” he wrote in The West Australian on November 18.

The natural response is to ask why anybody should believe Cameron Bancroft now. Fair question. I’d like to ask its neglected twin: What made him any more believable then?

open magazine cover
Open Magazine Latest Edition is Out Now!

The Wealth Issue 2026

06 Nov 2026 - Vol 05 | Issue 45

Portraits of Dreamers and Doers under 35

Read Now The Wealth Issue 2026

THE MOST IMPORTANT WORD WAS ‘ONLY’

On March 27, 2018, James Sutherland, then Cricket Australia’s chief executive, announced the preliminary findings in Johannesburg. Steve Smith, David Warner and Bancroft were being sent home. Sutherland also told the public that the three were the only members of the squad who had prior knowledge of the plan. The following day, Australian cricket’s own website published a reader’s guide. To the question of who else knew, it gave an admirably clear answer: nobody else on the playing or coaching staff.

I keep coming back to that little word, only. Cricket Australia had every right to punish the men against whom it had evidence. It had an equal duty to protect other players from punishment by association. It could have discharged both obligations by saying it had found evidence against three men and had insufficient grounds to charge anyone else. Instead, it told Australia how many people knew.

Consider what happens to a bowler under those two formulations. Under the first, he keeps his place because nobody has established a case against him. Quite right, too. Under the second, the board has vouched for what he knew before he went out to bowl. That is a considerably more ambitious piece of detective work. If Cricket Australia had independent evidence good enough to make that distinction in 2018, producing it now would do more for the reputations of those bowlers than another declaration of support.

WHAT DID A FAST BOWLER KNOW?

Give Pat Cummins the strongest argument available to him. A fast bowler asks the teammate looking after the ball whether it is reverse-swinging. Of course he does. He wants to know whether his next delivery might bend back into a right-hander. The exchange establishes that two cricketers discussed the condition of a cricket ball. On its own, it tells us nothing about whether the bowler knew there was sandpaper in somebody’s pocket.

Bancroft recalls discussing the ball’s behaviour with the fast bowlers. He also makes the much more serious allegation that the whole team knew he was using sandpaper. Usman Khawaja’s memoir, Sabr, had already challenged the official account. Cummins disputes it. In 2021, he, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon jointly denied knowing about the plan. Nobody acquires knowledge of a conspiracy merely by being good at reverse swing. Equally, four signatures on a denial cannot settle what eleven individuals knew at different times.

Here is where the dates matter. The original finding concerned prior knowledge of the Cape Town plan. Bancroft now says he withheld information about when the use of sandpaper began and how long it continued. A teammate who learnt something after the event belongs in a different account from one who saw sandpaper used earlier on the tour. A man who heard a suggestion belongs in a different account again. Ask eleven players whether “everybody knew” and they could spend another eight years arguing about it. Ask each man when he first saw the stuff, who was beside him and what was said, and at least two accounts can be checked against each other.

THE PRICE OF BEING IN THE PICTURE

There is something painfully human about what finally moved Bancroft to write. By his account, it was hearing Cummins dismiss the allegations at a press conference. Imagine the peculiar authority of that occasion. One man gets to speak about Cape Town as the captain of Australia. The other will be introduced for the rest of his life as the bloke who put sandpaper down his trousers. Bancroft played just two more Tests after that tour. Whatever weight one gives his testimony, the camera settled his place in cricket history with an efficiency no inquiry could hope to match.

That gives him a powerful interest in widening the frame. It also gives him a perspective nobody else can supply. He alone can explain why he chose to leave things out of his interview. His stated desire to protect others deserves scrutiny. So does his extraordinary suggestion that he thought he was protecting the investigation itself. What did a young Australian Test player understand the purpose of an integrity investigation to be, if he believed he could serve it by withholding relevant information? We ought to hear his answer before turning him into either a whistleblower or a liar whose usefulness expired in 2018.

Cricket Australia has now announced an independent forum for players and staff, while declining to reopen the original investigation. There is merit in giving men who shared a dressing room somewhere to speak without fear of fresh sanctions. There is also a limit to what an invitation to talk can achieve. Suppose two former teammates give incompatible accounts of the same conversation. Will anyone put the discrepancy to both of them? Will the forum have access to what each told investigators in 2018? And if the evidence no longer supports the word only, who has the authority to correct the record?

Cricket has always been rather pleased with the phrase “the gentleman’s game”. At Cape Town, a television camera caught a gentleman cheating. The sport coped with that. It sent three men home and got on with the next Test. The harder trial of that old boast comes now, when the cameras can offer no further assistance and telling the truth may require Australian cricket to revise something it has said about itself for eight years.

Eleven Australians played at Newlands. Three paid the price. I have no quarrel with the number three. I’d just like Cricket Australia to show its working.