Should You Buy a Nano?

Let’s be honest, Tata Motors hasn’t handled the situation properly. They might appoint a 20-member high powered team to investigate the fires. The committee might conclude that the car is ‘absolutely safe’ with ‘no manufacturing defects’. Three months ago they even assured us that safety inspections would be carried out on customer cars and service would be provided free of cost wherever required (stopping short of an official recall). But if everything were okay, yet another Nano wouldn’t go up in flames in Delhi. 

So what could possibly be wrong?

The very first cases were traced to faulty combination switches on the steering column (Tata Motors prefers to call it smoke cases though there’s rarely smoke without a fire). Some speculate that the insulation casing on the wire was so thin that it melted, causing a short circuit. It’s logical to assume another electrical problem led to these fires. An automobile is surprisingly combustible and a spark next to something very hot could lead to a fire. Or maybe, was it a faulty (or poor quality) fuel line that could drip fuel onto the hot exhaust or some other part of the engine? Or a quality slip-up at the assembly stage where the fuel line isn’t fixed properly? Or poor quality components supplied by vendors who have had to slice costs viciously?

I’ve heard some people attributing the fire to the road-side electrician who cuts up the wiring harness to install a stereo or central locking. But the same guys have been cutting up wires in Marutis for years and I don’t remember them going up in flames.

There’s also a school of thought that says that since the Nano was built under such a tight and unprecedented cost control regime, some crucial steps in the testing process were skipped, tests that could have revealed problem areas. The thing is nobody can say anything for sure; there’s a mound of speculation, but little clarity from the manufacturer.

What’s needed here is reassurance, clarity and leadership. Nobody less than the Chairman needs to stand up and assure and guarantee owners (and potential customers) that there’s nothing wrong with the Nano. And get to the bottom of these recurring fires. 

There is a problem somewhere. But I want to add that I don’t think it is endemic to all Nanos. There are, after all, tens of thousands of Nanos on the road, and we’ve only heard of six cases of fire. Even if you double that number to account for unreported or hushed up cases, that’s still a very small fraction. Over the year, we’ve sampled scores of Nanos, tested them vigorously, driven them to all parts of the country, an Overdrive reader even drove one up to Leh (and came back in one piece!)—and the car has proved itself admirably. On a price-to-performance barometer, the Nano still bests every single car sold in the country.

And I still recommend it highly, provided no more problems surface down the line. It’s a shame it is often in the news for all the wrong reasons.