Sympathy will accrue to President Trump on this one. Americans see illegal immigrants as striking at the heart of fairness. It is easily observed that illegal immigration rewards rule breakers while lawful citizens wait
A law enforcement officer uses tear gas on a protester in Los Angeles, June 11, 2025 (Photo: Reuters)
THE SWORD ARM of the hard Left has drawn an arc of incendiary violence across Los Angeles, California. What you’re seeing on the smoking boulevards of the traditionally liberal American city is but a snapshot of the wildfire of recent confrontational leftist activism. This isn’t just discontent. It is anarchical mobilisation masquerading as discontent. Every fiery munition set off by the agitators is part of a deliberate machination to bash Washington DC into moral submission.
It’s true. Trump’s administration has not exactly been above reproach. It has after all been provocatively referring to America’s immigration problem as a “war for the future of civilization”. Nonetheless, the effect—a full-fledged leftist Intifada against US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents— isn’t doing any favours to the liberal cause either.
Surely, there is little moral justification for preventing the Trump-led Federal administration from doing its primary duty: securing the nation’s borders.
Though a petulant populist, sympathy will accrue to President Trump on this one. Americans, cutting across ideological and political lines, see illegal immigrants as striking at the heart of fairness. It is easily observed that illegal immigration rewards rule breakers while lawful citizens wait.
No wonder then that an increasing number of Americans, at a time when economic prospects are seen to be receding, are aligned with the commonsense view that a porous border is not compassion but an invitation to “cultural invaders” and “economic parasites”.
Indians are very familiar with the contours of the debate on illegal immigration.
In fact, the way the violence, the divisive rhetoric and the resultant political partisanship over the issue is playing out in the US has some obvious parallels with the anti-CAA-NRC agitation in India. Back in late 2019, the Indian Left arrayed itself against the Modi government’s legal moves to “rectify historical wrongs”. The Modi government passed an amendment to the Citizenship Act offering a haven to persecuted minorities from neighbouring Islamic republics. It also announced that it would keep count of illegal immigrants by maintaining a National Register for Citizens (NRC) .
Then, like now, the Opposition led by Congress vehemently opposed the Modi government’s policies mischievously casting the CAA-NRC as a divisive stratagem aimed at othering “Indian Muslims”. Soon urban centres erupted in protests. Shaheen Bagh became a flashpoint, its “organic” resistance amplified by global media echo chambers and curated activist networks around the world.
Just as in America today, border control was equated with xenophobia and legality with Parliament abetted majoritarianism.
The NDA felt compelled to launch a counter-narrative. UP Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath put it simply, remarking that “80 per cent were being held hostage to violence by 20 per cent.”
The polarising impact of Adityanath’s plainspeak cut both ways. The NDA and its ideological adversaries on the Left consolidated their respective electoral bases.
And this is also what the Left in the US, desperate for political rehabilitation, is hoping will happen as it aligns itself to anarchists in Los Angeles.
From Delhi to DC, the Left now views illegal immigration as a pressure point. A demographic lever, a vote bank in gestation. But above and beyond it sees illegal immigration as a moral cudgel to beat down ideological opponents and snatch political turf.
The toolkit is no longer a theory. It is a transnational tactic. There’s no denying that despite their recent differences, Delhi and DC are together at the vanguard of a global contest between advocates for unapologetic sovereignty and the supporters of subversive transnational idealism.
More Columns
Alongside Dharavi Recast, Adani Lines Up Goregaon, Malad, BKC Slum Clusters Fast-Fast! Short Post
Land of a Hundred Thousand Welcomes — Just Not for Indians Alan Moore
From Entertainment to Baiting Scammers, The Journey of Two YouTubers Madhavankutty Pillai