Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer comeback: Has Scrooge brought Hollywood back on his side?

For a man whose career has been shadowed by courtroom battles and controversy, playing Ebenezer Scrooge, the miser who gets a second chance at redemption, is an unusually loaded choice. But has Johnny Depp found his own second act? His new film Ebenezer, directed by Ti West, has made a promising start at the box office. Whether that translates into a full-fledged Hollywood comeback is another question.
Can Johnny Depp’s $42 million opening signal a comeback?
Released in the US and several international markets on November 13, Ebenezer collected an estimated $19 million in North America and another $23 million overseas, taking its worldwide opening to $42 million. Paramount confirmed that the Charles Dickens adaptation debuted at No. 1 globally, with a reported production budget of $38 million.
The Wealth Issue 2026
06 Nov 2026 - Vol 05 | Issue 45
Portraits of Dreamers and Doers under 35
According to reports, this is Depp’s first studio-film opening at the top of the North American box office in eight years. The result is encouraging, particularly after a prolonged absence from major Hollywood productions. But the opening weekend alone cannot establish whether the film will be profitable: marketing costs, theatrical revenue-sharing and its performance in the weeks ahead will matter.
What are critics and audiences saying about Depp as Scrooge?
The early response is strikingly divided. Ebenezer received an A- CinemaScore from opening-day audiences and a 90% Verified Hot audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. However, its critics’ score has hovered around the low-to-mid 50s, suggesting that professional reviewers are considerably less impressed.
Film critic Peter Bradshaw found Depp effective as the irritable, theatrical Scrooge, but felt the actor was less convincing once the character begins his transformation. Another was harsher, arguing that Depp’s familiar performance mannerisms overwhelm the role and that the adaptation brings little new to Dickens’ story.
Some early reactions on social media were more enthusiastic, praising Depp’s performance and the film’s gothic atmosphere. Others called the retelling predictable. The split suggests that his loyal fan base may be more invested in his return than critics are in the film itself.
Why is Ebenezer such an important film for Johnny Depp?
This is Depp’s first major Hollywood production since the 2022 defamation trial involving his former wife, Amber Heard. The controversy had already affected his career: in 2020, Warner Bros asked him to leave the Fantastic Beasts franchise after he lost a UK libel case against The Sun. He was replaced as Grindelwald.
In the 2022 Virginia trial, a jury found in Depp’s favour on three defamation claims relating to Heard’s 2018 opinion article. It also found in Heard’s favour on one counterclaim involving a statement by Depp’s former lawyer. The jury awarded damages to both, and the parties later settled the appeal.
Is Hollywood ready to welcome Depp back?
Ebenezer is a significant test, not a final verdict. Depp has continued working outside the Hollywood studio system, including in the French film Jeanne du Barry, while also directing Modi: Three Days on the Wing of Madness. His next major American release, Day Drinker, is expected in 2027.
The film’s opening suggests that audiences have not forgotten his star power. But a box-office debut cannot settle questions about his public reputation or personal accountability. Nor does a positive audience score guarantee a lasting comeback.
For now, Scrooge may have found redemption on screen. Whether Depp can rebuild his place in Hollywood will depend on what comes after the opening weekend.
