Rahul’s Modi Obsession: It is a testament to his political naiveté

Rahul Gandhi talks and thinks incessantly about Prime Minister Narendra Modi. He seeks to debate him one-on-one, prosecute him, remove him from office, and even jail him. Rahul’s obsession with Modi is not entirely unsurprising. As Leader of the Opposition (LoP), he needs to challenge Modi on India’s economic, foreign and security policies.
All democracies work like that. But other countries do it differently. They debate ferociously in, for example, Britain’s House of Commons where, at 12PM every Wednesday during Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQ), the prime minister is hauled over the coals. But there is no personal abuse.
In India, the abuse started with mautkasaudagar (merchant of death), an epithet Sonia Gandhi hurled at Modi in 2007. Modi was then chief minister of Gujarat. Sonia was chairperson of the Congress-led UPA and the shadow prime minister behind Manmohan Singh.
Modi called her a Jersey cow but surprisingly has spared Rahul from abuse apart from mocking him as a failed dynast. Modi has never called Rahul a chor or chowkidar though he has accused Congress of being corrupt. Rahul’s intemperate behaviour has two underlying causes. In India, people of a certain social class look down on those who don’t “belong”. This makes it easier for them to be dismissive of those they regard as their social inferiors. Rahul has led a life of luxury, travelling abroad frequently. Modi in contrast has led a very different life. He was born into a poor family and rose up the ranks in, first, RSS and then BJP.
In her memoir Belonging, Sonia Gandhi says she understood Modi’s initial sense of alienation in Lutyens’ old ecosystem of privilege when he first became prime minister. She herself had felt “ill at ease” among a crowd in a room when she was new to India.
Sonia was a quick learner. Her father, Stefano Maino, was a self-declared fascist who refused to attend Sonia’s wedding with Rajiv. He had at first opposed the marriage to an “Indian”, an indication of deep-rooted racism along with lifelong fascism in Mussolini’s Italy. Sonia learnt quickly in the few years she spent in England, and the decades she has spent in India, that the route to social acceptability is to be left-of-centre and secular. She noticed that the most entitled people she met in India were leftists who made it a point to show their solidarity with Muslims. Secularism and socialism were posh. Nationalism and capitalism were not.
Modi was a nationalist. Leftists said that was a proxy for being majoritarian which in turn was a proxy for being communal. For India’s nouveau posh elite, Modi ticked all the wrong boxes. Not only was Modi communal, he was a capitalist. The British-educated nouveau elite are taught to look down on the trading class.
Rahul will be 60 years old in just over three years. He knows that if the Congress-led I.N.D.I.A. bloc loses the 2029 Lok Sabha election, its task in 2034 will be even harder. India is becoming an increasingly nationalist country. For Modi’s leftwing critics that means India is becoming more majoritarian and more communal. But if India’s 79 per cent Hindus were to vote en masse for BJP as Muslims do for the opposition, it would have won every election hands down. In fact, it has lost several state Assembly elections.
Rahul knows that, despite being 20 years younger than Modi, he doesn’t have time on his side. India is changing—and it is changing in a direction that will not help a left-leaning party like Congress. The only solution, Rahul believes, is to urgently attack the head of this majoritarian movement: Narendra Modi. Rahul’s simplistic thesis is that if you disempower Modi and his second in-command, Home Minister Amit Shah, the whole BJP edifice will come crashing down.
It would be a testament to Rahul’s political naiveté if he actually believes this thesis. Perhaps he privately doesn’t. He may have searched Modi’s pocket when he hugged him in Parliament and instead of finding Adani lurking there, found a copy of the Constitution. Rahul has begun carrying the red-bound book, obsessively, wherever he goes.